Skip to content

SEY-UC-005 · Issue 1, Rev A · September 2026

No item that must be held reached air in three blind runs

A small television newsroom run by models, with one human editor. The producer decides what airs and holds every item that must not, each with one reason.

The test, in figures

0 of 15
Must-hold items aired, worst of three runs
15 of 15
Must-hold items held with a reason, in each run
1 of 15
Must-hold items aired by the baseline, a list of 51 blocked words
0
Items published without sign-off in the build
From the recorded test runs of 29 September 2026. The full method and every figure are in the paper.

The problem

H.E. Mohammad Al Gergawi, the UAE Minister of Cabinet Affairs, asked on the record whether tomorrow needs a whole television station, with staff and a billion budget. He also called artificial intelligence a danger to today's media. The danger sits in one decision: what reaches air.

The build

The newsroom reads the wire from three public feeds. The producer builds the running order and puts each item on air or holds it with one reason. A fact-check desk checks every story on air against the rest of the wire, and a writer scripts each story in Arabic and English. The channel is fictional, and every bulletin says aloud and on screen that artificial intelligence made it.

The test

The producer was tested on 25 labelled wire items: 10 real items that may air and 15 that must be held. In three blind runs, 0 of the 15 must-hold items reached air. The baseline, a list of 51 blocked words, aired a fake public holiday. Two real bulletins were cut from the 27 September wire of 114 items.

What a person still decides

The editor's sign-off, a recorded approval, comes before anything paid is made or published.

Read the full paper

Issue 1, Rev A, September 2026. It gives the problem, the design and the test, with every source and the file each figure comes from. Read the full paper as a PDF.

Have a job like this?